Accurate as of May 19th 2024

Wine Clubs comparison made easy


Top6 Score


Offers a personalized selection of wines based on your taste preferences established through an initial quiz.

Known for its focus on small production and unique wines, often featuring lesser-known vineyards

Provides flexibility in shipments, with options to skip months and easy cancellation.

Features an easy-to-use platform that allows users to rate the wines, which Winc uses to refine future selections.

Praised for its modern approach to wine curation and emphasis on customer experience.

Wine Insiders

Top6 Score

Wine Insiders

Offers expertly curated wines available for one-time purchases or as part of a non-subscription membership.

Known for its exceptional value, offering high-quality wines at competitive prices.

Provides detailed tasting notes and pairing recommendations with each bottle.

Features a satisfaction guarantee, with a commitment to replace or refund any wines that do not meet expectations.

Celebrated for its educational content that enhances the wine drinking experience.

Naked Wines

Top6 Score

Naked Wines

Operates on a unique model where customers (Angels) fund independent winemakers in exchange for exclusive access to wines at wholesale prices.

Known for its vibrant community of wine lovers and direct interaction with winemakers.

Offers a wide range of wines, including rare and limited editions.

Provides feedback opportunities directly to winemakers, influencing future productions.

Recognized for its strong focus on quality and innovation in winemaking.

Macy's Wine Cellar

Top6 Score

Macy's Wine Cellar

Provides a curated selection of wines tailored to seasonal themes and occasions.

Offers membership options that include quarterly wine shipments, with each selection handpicked by experts.

Known for its special occasion gift selections and wine sets.

Includes tasting notes and a serving guide with each shipment.

Features an introductory offer with significant savings on the first shipment, making it a great gift option.

Wine Access

Top6 Score

Wine Access

Specializes in offering access to premium and allocated wines that are often not available in typical retail channels.

Known for its deep expertise and extensive research that goes into each selection.

Provides rich stories behind each wine, enhancing the appreciation of its origin and winemaker.

Offers a range of membership clubs tailored to different wine preferences and consumption habits.

Praised for its exceptional customer service and educational approach to wine selling.

Plonk Wine Club

Top6 Score

Plonk Wine Club

Focuses on environmentally responsible wines, including organic, biodynamic, and naturally produced varieties.

Known for its commitment to showcasing wines made with minimal intervention.

Each shipment includes detailed tasting notes, vineyard profiles, and food pairing suggestions.

Offers a variety of club options, including red only, white only, and mixed cases.

Receives high marks for its dedication to wine purity and environmental sustainability.